Change NHS: a look at submissions

In November 2024 the UK public were invited by Health & Social Care Secretary, Wes Streeting, to contribute ideas to rescue the NHS; “Our NHS is broken, but not beaten. Together we can fix it.” See details here: https://change.nhs.uk/en-GB/

Amazingly the previous government left Cancer care out of its 10-year plan altogether. Given the scale of the current statistics this was surely deeply misjudged. In this blog I cover the excellent response by Yes to Life and note some other key points.

Robin Daly, Founder and Chair of Yes to Life, writes: "This was the introduction to Change NHS, a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to have our say, that we at Yes to Life immediately knew we had to respond to. Although there are no certainties as to what effect this unprecedented public input will have, we felt the need to express clearly the changes we would like to see, and to argue the case that these will provide solutions to many of the key ills affecting UK healthcare in the twenty-first century".

Yes to Life have now made their submission public. It relates strongly to the Charter for Oncology that Yes to Life published earlier this year. This Charter sets out "the ethos for an entirely new relationship between those delivering and those in need of healthcare, one that opens up unlimited potential for rapid improvements in resources, methods and most importantly results, as well as approaches to prevention and health promotion that are currently totally absent from mainstream healthcare".

Don't forget to sign the petition for the Charter: https://www.change.org/p/implement-the-yes-to-life-charter-for-oncology-in-all-nhs-cancer-units

The Yes to Life submission by Robin Daly and Dr Penny Kechagioglou, NHS Oncologist and Lead Advisor to Yes to Life on Integrative Oncology, can be read at: https://yestolife.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/Change-NHS-Booklet-1.pdf

The Charter is a key element of the submission but also there are other key points that they make in more detail than I note here - these include:

- The need for a deep cultural shift towards patient-centred care (not lip service) - it has been enshrined in the NHS Charter but is still barely discernible. Similarly we need a return to clinical judgement as a key element of evidence-based decisions.

- Integrative Oncology as a model of care is well developed in other countries, cost-effective and has better clinical outcomes; lifestyle changes are key yet the NHS is ill-equipped to deliver

- Prevention is ultimately where solutions lie

- More collaboration both within the NHS and with external providers

- More than half of Cancer patients adopt lifestyle or complementary approaches independently but are unsupported during and after treatment. Clinicians don't need to be experts but do need to know facts when it comes to its potential. Training key to help with changes.

- Improvements to data

The Patients Association

Many organisations and individuals are submitting responses  to Change NHS. One of the others I've read is by the Patients Association - see here. Their submission also strongly calls for the patient voice to be heard. It is full of detail and is informed by 290 responses to a call they made for comments. They found that the respondents to their survey were generally in favour of the three shifts proposed by the Government – shifting from hospitals to the community; from analogue to digital; and from sickness to prevention. There was also an understanding about the challenges that may arise from implementing these shifts. 

Among the key points are calls for shorter waiting times, integrated digital health records, better prevention strategies, and equitable care for underserved groups. Workforce recruitment and retention, alongside stronger patient partnerships, were also seen as critical to success.

One key issues that impacts on the NHS that needs emphasising is around how social determinants of health impact patients. This includes external factors that contribute to a patient’s health and wellbeing, like their income level, if they have access to safe housing, and whether they come from a minoritised community, like being Black or LGBTQ+. This is huge and something this blog has touched on in the past. Again as we've argued in the past part of the answers involve really involving patients.

Lastly here's a link to World Cancer Research Funds submission which also has some good stuff: https://www.wcrf.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/Comments-10-year-health-plan-England-Dec-2024.pdf